what is more efficient is a matter of personal preference, imho both are equal effective (or the reflector is better because of less losses)
but this has been typed and argued over and over ...
Most easy:
You want quite a spot with some sidespill (throw is Your primary concern) --> reflector
You want less throw but a larger primary illumination area --> optic
The IMS model You posted is the 27 mm diameter version with most throw, then there are also 17 and 20 mm available. MOST important if You do not have much space to get the means of focusing in.
I think these IMS are on par with any optic, also similar priced. The real expensive reflectors are more difficult to get ...
here, again, my photos of choice. Both Lux 1 about same current, about same bright.
Unfortunately the one with the optic, on the right, is a very early one with some kind of green (note: in my opinion the optic worsens the color of the led).
Optic is an 8 degree Fraen, situated on the right.
5 cm from wall
1/2 m from wall
1 m
2 m
4 m
You see how the reflector holds the tight spot and the optic looses the focus? Still both hotspots are about the same size, even when there is more way to the wall. For me: the optic is way worse.